Teddi Mellencamp and Edwin Arroyave's separation has recently come under scrutiny, revealing that Arroyave allegedly had an affair with a woman named Missy during their 13-year marriage. Multiple sources have confirmed details surrounding the timeline and implications of this relationship.

"Marriage Crisis: Teddi Mellencamp's Divorce Following Infidelity and Custody Battle Rumors"

Details of the Alleged Affair

Sources indicate that Edwin Arroyave, 47, began a romantic relationship with Missy between 2015 and 2016, with the duration of the affair estimated to be "at least a year" according to one insider, while another believes it spanned closer to "six months." The first source characterized Missy as Mellencamp's "best friend," but a contrasting account suggests that the two women only interacted a handful of times. The affair came to light for Mellencamp, 43, in March 2016, coinciding with her auditions for Season 8 of The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills.

"Marriage Crisis: Teddi Mellencamp's Divorce Following Infidelity and Custody Battle Rumors"

Challenges in Marriage and Commitment

Mellencamp previously acknowledged that she and Arroyave nearly ended their marriage that same year. One source revealed that Arroyave was prepared to leave Mellencamp when she discovered the affair, but she sought to reconcile. Following this revelation, Arroyave purportedly committed to Mellencamp, vowing to "close that chapter" of his life. Despite his infidelity, the second source claims that this experience prompted significant personal reflection, leading to a renewed emphasis on family and faith.

"Marriage Crisis: Teddi Mellencamp's Divorce Following Infidelity and Custody Battle Rumors"

Ongoing Speculations and Current Status

While Mellencamp remains uncertain about the extent of Arroyave's unfaithfulness, there are conflicting viewpoints regarding the aftermath. The second source insists that Arroyave has not repeated his past behavior. Representatives for both parties declined to comment on the situation. Notably, this disclosure of Arroyave's affair surfaced just a day after reports confirmed Mellencamp's own involvement with her married horse trainer, Simon Schroeder, which ultimately led to her filing for divorce.

"Marriage Crisis: Teddi Mellencamp's Divorce Following Infidelity and Custody Battle Rumors"

Divorce Proceedings and Custody Requests

The source explains that Mellencamp's relationship with Schroeder reportedly began in May while his wife was in California. Upon returning to Los Angeles, Postel allegedly discovered concerning messages between her husband and Mellencamp, leading to a public confrontation. Both women were reportedly aware of their partners' indiscretions, with Mellencamp assuring that it would not happen again. However, the situation escalated when Postel learned that the relationship had not only persisted but had taken on emotional dimensions. Following this, Mellencamp officially announced her divorce via Instagram, seeking primary custody of their three children while Arroyave requested joint custody. In the face of the separation, Arroyave has hinted at his struggles through cryptic social media posts.