Melbourne Faces Criticism Over Clayton Oliver's Controversial Contract and Future Uncertainty
Melbourne's list management strategy has come under fire as Clayton Oliver, a four-time best and fairest winner, faces uncertainty after a tumultuous pre-season. Despite a lucrative contract extending to 2030, Oliver's relationship with the club appears strained, resulting in discussions about a potential move to Geelong. The club's management is criticized for offering what is viewed as one of the worst contracts in AFL history, as Oliver navigates a challenging phase in his career.
Kane Cornes has criticized Melbourne's list management approach as the club seeks to part ways with four-time best and fairest winner Clayton Oliver, who is currently facing numerous personal and performance challenges.
Clayton Oliver's Current Struggles and Contract Situation
Clayton Oliver, who signed a lucrative contract extension in mid-2022 that secures him with Melbourne until the end of 2030, has faced a tumultuous period since. Despite being at the peak of his performance at that time, Oliver managed to play only 15 games in 2023, struggling through a troubling pre-season in 2024. He was reportedly shopped around to other clubs, had to take personal leave, and even spent time in the hospital, highlighting the difficulties surrounding his time with the club.
Relationship Breakdown Between Oliver and Melbourne
The relationship between the player and the club has increasingly deteriorated, with indications that both parties are keen to part ways. Oliver recently met with officials and players from Geelong and expressed a desire to wear their colors in 2025, despite acknowledging the challenges posed by his existing contract.
Criticism of Melbourne's Management Strategy
Kane Cornes has publicly criticized Melbourne's management strategies, labeling Oliver's contract as potentially the worst in AFL history. As Oliver's seven-year contract has now entered its second year with six remaining, questions arise over the financial implications. Cornes mentioned that there is still $10 million left on the deal, averaging at $1.3 million per year, and highlighted the complexities that may hinder any potential trade, particularly regarding how much of the salary Geelong would be willing to cover.
Oliver's Response to Critics and Future Outlook
In facing the criticisms, Oliver defended Melbourne's culture and emphasized his understanding that a rigorous off-season is necessary for his career. He expressed intent to engage in early training sessions to prepare for the upcoming season and alleviate media scrutiny. Additionally, the club is expected to lose Jim Plunkett, their head of leadership, further complicating the environment surrounding Oliver.
